Skip to Content

Florida Supreme Court Rules In Favor Of Consumers In Med Mal Battle


Nurse Thinking of Something by the Corridor

Should a person who’s suffered a grievous injury due to the mistake of a medical professional or hospital have the right to sue for the disfigurement, pain, and suffering (called non-economic damages) of that mistake?

That’s a question that has roiled the nation for years and led some states to consider capping damage awards.

Where does the concept of capping originate?

Doctors and hospitals have long advanced the idea. They claim such awards add immense costs to healthcare.

The State of Florida enacted such a cap in 2003, one intended to limit damage awards for just these kinds of losses.

Was that law appropriate, fair, or constitutional?

The Florida Supreme Court has just issued a decision in this matter in a case involving a woman who had her esophagus mistakenly perforated during surgery for carpal tunnel syndrome.

The case involved a dental assistant who underwent surgery for carpal tunnel syndrome and ended up with a perforated esophagus. To repair the damage, surgery on her neck and back were required – as was a drug-induced three-week coma. A jury at the time awarded her $4.7 million for the traumas she endured. A circuit judge later overturned that award, citing the 2003 law limiting damages in such cases.

Though that decision was overturned by an appeals court, the defendants sought a final ruling from the Florida Supreme Court.

Florida’s highest court decided the issue in favor of the injured woman, stating that state statutes establishing caps on “noneconomic damages” in medical malpractice personal injury cases are unconstitutional.

Perhaps as important is this conclusion reached by the Court:

“We further conclude that because there is no evidence of a continuing medical malpractice insurance crisis justifying the arbitrary and invidious discrimination between medical malpractice victims, there is no rational relationship between the personal injury noneconomic damage caps in section 766.118 and alleviating this purported crisis. Therefore, we hold that the caps on personal injury noneconomic damages provided in section 766.118 violate the Equal Protection Clause of the Florida Constitution.”

Is the Court correct in this instance? Is there no evidence of a continuing medical malpractice insurance crisis?

A recent review of malpractice claims by Johns Hopkins researchers suggests any assertions claiming a crisis linked to medical malpractice claims are, in fact, wrong.

In their review of malpractice payouts of more than $1 million, researchers said those payments added up to about $1.4 billion a year – for less than one (1) percent of all national medical expenditures.

“The notion that frivolous claims are routinely resulting in $100 million payouts is not true,” said study leader Dr. Marty Makary, associate professor of surgery and health policy at Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine.

At Riscassi & Davis, we believe we are all better off when there are checks and balances on power. Neither corporations nor powerful individuals should be able to escape responsibility for harm done to others.

For more than 60 years, the attorneys at RisCassi & Davis have fought hard in the courts and in the legislature to protect the legitimate rights of Connecticut consumers. In matters of medical malpractice, we unequivocally believe that consumers have the constitutional right to sue medical providers for the pain, suffering, and disfigurement caused by medical errors and will work tirelessly to protect those rights.

If you or a loved one is ever the victim of a surgical error, a defective drug, the improper prescription of a drug therapy, over-exposure to medical radiation, a hospital-acquired infection, a fall while in the hospital, a preventable blood clot, a misdiagnosis, or any form of medical malpractice, call a qualified Connecticut medical malpractice lawyer. A knowledgeable medical malpractice lawyer can help to ensure that your rights are protected.

RisCassi & Davis has handled hundreds of medical malpractice cases over our more than 60 years serving the people of Connecticut.

What’s more, our Connecticut medical malpractice lawyers have received local and national recognition for our handling of these cases.

We have a great team of legal experts dedicated to medical malpractice in Connecticut. Please contact us if we can help you.

The consultation is free and there is no obligation of any kind.

Contact Us Real Lawyers. Real Results

Schedule Your Free Consultation

Call Us Today (860) 245-2412
  • Please enter your first name.
  • Please enter your last name.
  • Please enter your phone number.
    This isn't a valid phone number.
  • Please enter your email address.
    This isn't a valid email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.
  • By submitting, you agree to be contacted about your request & other information using automated technology. Message frequency varies. Msg & data rates may apply. Text STOP to cancel. Acceptable Use Policy